General
- Theoretical security issues with no realistic exploit scenario(s) or attack surfaces, or issues that would require complex end user interactions to be exploited
- Spam, social engineering and physical intrusion
- DoS/DDoS attacks or brute force attacks
- Vulnerabilities that only work on software that no longer receive security updates
- Attacks requiring physical access to a victim's computer/device, man in the middle or compromised user accounts
- Recently discovered zero-day vulnerabilities found in in-scope assets within 14 days after the public release of a patch or mitigation may be reported, but are usually not eligible for a bounty
- Reports that state that software is out of date/vulnerable without a proof-of-concept
Duplicates
Vulnerabilities that were already known to the BMW Group through our own testing will be flagged as duplicate.
Vulnerabilities that were already reported to the BMW Group will be flagged as duplicate.
During our transitional phase:
For vulnerabilities that have already been reported via our old program at HackerOne but have not yet been resolved, no new bounties will be paid out. These cases are examined individually by the triage team and us and, if applicable, will be closed with a corresponding notice.
This problem will only exist during a transitional period.
Assets
- Everything not explicitly listed as in scope
- All subdomains of the domains in scope
- Pages redirecting to non-BMW domains
Vulnerabilities
- Wordpress usernames disclosure
- Pre-Auth Account takeover/OAuth squatting
- Self-XSS that can't be used to exploit other users
- Verbose messages/files/directory listings without disclosing any sensitive information
- CORS misconfiguration on non-sensitive endpoints
- Missing cookie flags
- Missing security headers
- Cross-site Request Forgery with no or low impact
- Presence of autocomplete attribute on web forms
- Reverse tabnabbing
- Bypassing rate-limits or the non-existence of rate-limits.
- Best practices violations (password complexity, expiration, re-use, etc.)
- Clickjacking without proven impact/unrealistic user interaction
- CSV Injection
- Sessions not being invalidated (logout, enabling 2FA, etc.)
- Tokens leaked to third parties
- Anything related to email spoofing, SPF, DMARC or DKIM
- Content injection without being able to modify the HTML
- Username/email enumeration
- Email bombing
- HTTP Request smuggling without any proven impact
- Homograph attacks
- XMLRPC enabled
- Banner grabbing/Version disclosure
- Not stripping metadata of files
- Same-site scripting
- Subdomain takeover without taking over the subdomain
- Arbitrary file upload without proof of the existence of the uploaded file
- Blind SSRF without proven business impact (pingbacks aren't sufficient)
- API key disclosure without proven business impact
- Disclosed/misconfigured Google Maps API keys
- Host header injection without proven business impact
- CSRF logout
- Self-exploitation (e.g., token or cookie reuse)
- Broken links to third-party social media web pages (e.g., independent BMW Dealers, Resellers or Fanclubs)
- Blind XSS that cannot be verified: Blind XSS Triggers must be fired within a week after setting them up. If they cannot be verified by the triage team, the related report will be rejected
Post-exploitation
All post-exploitation is out of scope, except the minimum to prove that the exploit is working:
- In case of an RCE or injection attack, you may issue commands stating the version of the database, the system name or the local IP address
- All post exploitation that will lead to further vulnerabilities or risk the stability or integrity of a system is out of scope
Domains from independent BMW Dealers, Resellers or Fanclubs
We would like to point out that not every asset that has BMW (or one of its brands) in its name necessarily belongs to the BMW Group. The systems in question may include retailers, importers, service providers, fan clubs, or others. However, in many of these cases, we have limited or no influence on the actual owner of these systems. In these cases, the reports will be closed by the triage team or by us with a corresponding notice. These systems are not eligible for bounty or bonus.
No Bounty Domains
While not being covered by the safe harbor clause, vulnerabilities related to domains that are not in scope of this program can be reported by choosing the respective “Other BMW Domains” asset. Please consider that these assets are not eligible for any bounty. However, they may be eligible for a bonus.